Code Security Audit Report

Expert Human Review of AI-Generated Code

Project: TaskMaster SaaS Platform
Repository: github.com/example/taskmaster-app
Commit Hash: a7b3c9d
Review Date: July 15, 2025
Reviewer: Sarah Chen, Senior Security Engineer
Lines of Code: 4,247
Overall Risk: HIGH

Executive Summary

This audit identified 12 security vulnerabilities, 8 performance issues, and 5 architectural concerns in your AI-generated codebase. Critical issues include SQL injection vulnerabilities, exposed API keys, and inefficient database queries that could impact scalability.

Key Findings

Detailed Findings

ID Location Severity Category Description Effort
SEC-01 auth/login.py:47 CRITICAL Security SQL Injection in authentication query Medium
SEC-02 config/keys.py:12 CRITICAL Security Hardcoded API keys in source code Small
PERF-01 api/tasks.py:156 HIGH Performance N+1 query problem in task listing Medium
SEC-03 upload/files.py:89 HIGH Security Path traversal vulnerability in file upload Medium
SEC-04 utils/hash.py:23 MEDIUM Security Weak password hashing using MD5 Small

Critical Issue Analysis

SEC-01: SQL Injection Vulnerability

Location: auth/login.py, line 47

Risk: An attacker could steal all user data, modify records, or gain administrative access.

Vulnerable Code:

def authenticate_user(username, password): query = f"SELECT * FROM users WHERE username = '{username}' AND password = '{password}'" result = db.execute(query) return result.fetchone()

Recommended Fix:

def authenticate_user(username, password): query = "SELECT * FROM users WHERE username = %s AND password = %s" result = db.execute(query, (username, hash_password(password))) return result.fetchone()

Impact: This vulnerability allows SQL injection attacks through the login form. An attacker could use payloads like ' OR '1'='1 to bypass authentication or extract sensitive data.

SEC-02: Exposed API Keys

Location: config/keys.py, line 12

Risk: Exposed third-party service credentials could lead to unauthorized API usage and billing charges.

Vulnerable Code:

# Third-party API configurations STRIPE_SECRET_KEY = "sk_live_51H7..." SENDGRID_API_KEY = "SG.abc123..." AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY = "wJalrXUtnFEMI/K7MDENG/..."

Recommended Fix:

import os from dotenv import load_dotenv load_dotenv() STRIPE_SECRET_KEY = os.getenv('STRIPE_SECRET_KEY') SENDGRID_API_KEY = os.getenv('SENDGRID_API_KEY') AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY = os.getenv('AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY')

Impact: These credentials are visible in your Git history and could be discovered by attackers, leading to unauthorized access to your payment processing, email services, and cloud infrastructure.

Performance Issues

PERF-01: N+1 Query Problem

Location: api/tasks.py, line 156

Impact: This will cause severe performance degradation as your user base grows. With 1000 tasks, this code makes 1001 database queries instead of 2.

Inefficient Code:

def get_tasks_with_users(): tasks = Task.objects.all() # 1 query result = [] for task in tasks: user = User.objects.get(id=task.user_id) # N queries! result.append({ 'task': task, 'user': user }) return result

Optimized Code:

def get_tasks_with_users(): tasks = Task.objects.select_related('user').all() # 1 query with JOIN result = [] for task in tasks: result.append({ 'task': task, 'user': task.user # No additional query needed }) return result

Immediate Action Required

  • Fix SQL injection vulnerability before deploying to production
  • Remove all hardcoded credentials and implement environment variables
  • Rotate all exposed API keys immediately
  • Implement input validation on all user-facing endpoints
  • Upgrade password hashing to bcrypt or Argon2
  • Add rate limiting to prevent brute force attacks
  • Implement proper error handling to avoid information disclosure

Estimated fix time: 8-12 hours for critical issues, 16-20 hours for all identified problems.